Unraveling The Complexities Of Non-Compete Agreements In Employment Contracts

In India, Under The Indian Contract Act Of 1872 Non-Compete Clauses In Employment Contracts Are Allowed If They Do Not Contravene And Violate Stipulations Regarding Human Rights To Work. However, There Is Some Controversy Around The Definition Of A “Reasonable” Non-Compete Contract As Many Trade Union Activists And Also Employees Believe That Such Contracts Are Most Often Unfairly Wide.

Legal Provisions Regarding Non-Compete Agreements

• Indian Contract Act, 1872, Section 27: Under The Contract Law, Non-Compete Agreements Are Illegal. Section 27 States That Every Agreement, That Makes Any Person Abstain From The Profession, Trade, Or Business Of His Choosing In Whatever Form, Is Void On Account Of Its Part. From The Fact That Chapter Xxvii Prohibits The Restriction Of Trade, Section 27 Of The Contract Act Indian Courts Have Always Invalidated Post-Termination Non-Compete Clauses Under Employment Contracts. On The Contrary, They Have Held That Those Clauses Are Void And Against Public Policy As They May Deprive A Person Of Her Constitutional Right To Work.

• Article 19(G): Since Article 19(G) Of The Indian Constitution, Every Individual From India Has A Right To Engage In Any Kind And Manner That Defines Trading Business Or Profession. Since The Early Days, Courts Have Been Very Reluctant To Endorse Any Reasonable Limits On This Right And Kept Its Interpretation Malleable So That Justice Is Administered By The Moral Values Of Fairness Based Upon Particular Facts Of A Case. However, This Is Not An Absolute Right And Reasonable Restraints Can Be Placed On It For The Public Benefit.

The Nuances Of Noncompete Clauses In Employment Contracts

• The Scope: The Scope Of The Non-Compete Clauses Is One Of Their Main Issues. Though A New Job Might Not Directly Compete With An Employee’s Previous Employer, Too Broad Of Restrictions On Non-Compete Clauses Can Negatively Impact One’s Ability To Find Employment In The Preferred Field Or Industry. For Example, It Would Be Regarded As Too Expensive And Irrational For A Non-Compete Agreement To Prohibit An Engineer From Working At Any Technology Company In India After Five Years Of His/Her Departure From The Current Employer.

• However, The Indian Courts Have Repeatedly Thought That Noncompete Agreements Are Meant To Be Limited Only To Specific Commercial Interests That An Employer Wants To Protect. The Scope Of The Non-Compete Agreement Should Be Reasonable And Must Serve The Needs Of The Employer's Reasonable Interests. It Should Be Carefully Considered The Wording Of The Non-Compete Agreement To Ensure That It Only Covers What Is Specifically Protected By The Employer.

• The Non-Compete Clause's Duration: A Non-Compete Clause Is Also Too Long. A Very Long Non-Compete Agreement Can Significantly Impede An Employee’s Efforts To Look For A New Job And Make Ends Meet. Judgments From The Indian Courts Highlight That Non-Compete Agreements Must Not Exceed More Than Two Years. While Longer Terms Are Often Justified By Employers As A Means Of Protecting Their Assets, It Is Also Important To Note That The Interests Of Staff Members Must Also Be Addressed. You Should Align With Your Employer On The Length Of The Non-Compete Agreement That Makes It Reasonable And Reflects Everyone's Needs.

• Area Covered By The Non-Compete Provision: The Geographical Scope Of The Non-Compete Agreement Should Also Be Considered. For Instance, The Imposition Of A Non-Compete Agreement Concerning A Wide Geographical Region Or Country May Be Overly Harsh And Restrictive. The Decisions Of The Courts In India Have Clarified That The Territorial Limit Of The Non-Compete Agreement Must Be Narrowed Down To Regions Where An Employer Has A Valid Commercial Interest. For Example, If It Is A City Or Region In Which The Employer Operates, Then The Non-Compete Clause Must Only Apply To That Specific Operating Area. If The Company Has Multiple Branches, Then The Prohibition Of Competition Should Be Limited To Those Where There Is A Significant Commercial Base For That Particular Business.

• The Non-Compete Clause's Enforcement: Even If They Are Restricted By A Properly Drafted Narrowly Framed Non-Compete Agreement, An Employee’s Rights Getting Violated Or The Public Policy Being Broken May Render Such Agreements Unenforceable. Indian Courts Have Decided That Employers Cannot Use Non-Compete Arrangements To Prevent An Employee From Making A Living And Also Practicing Their Trade. In Addition, Non-Compete Contracts Should Not Demean The Act Of Unfair Labor Practices Or Force Employees Against Their Will. Companies Also Need To Ensure That The Non-Compete Agreement Is Consistent With All The Laws And Rules About Employment Relationships.

  
  

Lead India Provides Various Kinds Of Legal Services Which Include Free Legal Advice And Internet Information. One Can Talk To A Lawyer From Lead India For Any Kind Of Legal Support. In India, Free Legal Advice Online Can Be Obtained At Lead India. Along With Receiving Free Legal Advice Online, One Can Also Ask Questions To The Experts Online Free Through Lead India.

Read Also

Why Are Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs) Crucial In Business Transactions?

What Safety Measures Should You Take Before Getting Married In Court?